Lately we in contrast the Ryzen 7 5800X and Core i7-11700K in 32 video games operating at 1080p, 1440p and 4K utilizing the Radeon RX 6900 XT. By the conclusion of that shootout we commented that we might wish to re-run all of the benchmarks to incorporate the extra reasonably priced Core i7-10700K which has similarities, nonetheless extensively out there, and might internet you about $100 in financial savings, so right here we’re.
The concept of the unique comparability overview was to see how newest and biggest AMD and Intel 8-core/16-thread processors do towards one another and the place every firm stands by way of gaming efficiency. That’s to not say we’re recommending you race out and purchase both of these CPUs proper now. In actual fact, in our latest replace to the High 5 Greatest CPUs we selected the Core i7-10700 sequence as the most effective worth selection for players on a finances.
As of writing, the Ryzen 7 5800X will set you again $430 and the Core i7-11700K $400. Nonetheless, the older Core i7-10700K is ~20% cheaper at $330, and there’s additionally the locked model, the 10700F at simply $270 — most significantly, out of the field efficiency is nearly similar. For many builders, I’d advocate the F-SKU, however for the sake of this comparability the 10700K makes extra sense given it’s going up towards the 11700K and 5800X.
We’ll focus on worth and pricing in higher element in the direction of the top of this overview, after we have seen how every CPU performs towards the others. For testing we’ve used G.Talent’s 32GB TridentZ Neo DDR4-3800 CL14 reminiscence and for the Radeon 6900 XT.
For the AM4 platform we have the examined utilizing the MSI X570 Unify and for the LGA1200 platform the Gigabyte Z590 Aorus Grasp operating the most recent BIOS on each counts, and naturally, the most recent show drivers and Home windows 10 model out there.
In whole we’ve examined 32 video games at 1080p, 1440p and 4K, and we’ll have a look at the information for a few dozen titles after which get into the standard knowledge breakdown. So let’s do it…
Beginning with the Horizon Zero Daybreak, we see that at 1080p the 10700K is barely slower than the 11700K. We’re speaking a few 4% drop in efficiency, although that was sufficient to see the Ryzen 7 5800X pull forward by a 7% margin.
Actually not a giant distinction and as anticipated they’re lowered additional when growing the decision. The 11700K is simply 3% quicker at 1440p, whereas the 5800X was 6% quicker.
Then for these taking part in at 4K it actually doesn’t matter which of those CPUs you utilize, the expertise goes to be similar.
Transferring on to Watch Canines: Legion we discover a comparable state of affairs the place the 10700K is barely slower than the 11700K, and due to this fact additionally trails the 5800X. The margins are small although, the 5800X was 7% quicker at 1080p for instance and 6% quicker at 1440p, although curiously maintained a 5% margin at 4K, although we’re speaking about only a 3% distinction there.
Metro Exodus Enhanced performs simply as properly utilizing any of those CPUs, so right here we’re on no account CPU restricted with these 8-core/16-thread processors. Utilizing any of those architectures you’d doubtless must drop all the way down to 4c/8t to see a lower in efficiency, although at this level there are not any quad-core Cypress Cove or Zen 3 processors.
Subsequent up now we have Microsoft Flight Simulator 2020 and beforehand we discovered the Ryzen 7 5800X and Core i7-11700K to be very evenly matched utilizing the Radeon RX 6900 XT within the part of the sport we take a look at, which is the touchdown problem at Sydney airport in Australia.
Testing with the 10700K reveals very comparable efficiency below these take a look at situations. In actual fact, the Tenth-gen CPU was 4% quicker at 1080p when in comparison with the newer AMD and Intel fashions, and a pair of% quicker at 1440p. We’re speaking about slim margins, so total the expertise ought to be a lot the identical utilizing any of those processors.
Testing at 1080p in Cyberpunk 2077 beforehand revealed the 11700K to be a smidgen quicker than the 5800X, and with the 10700K we’ve discovered it to be barely quicker once more. We’re speaking a few slim 4% benefit in favor of the Tenth-gen half at 1080p. That margin is cleared when you play at 1440p.
As soon as once more we discover that it doesn’t matter which one in every of these 8-core processors you utilize for gaming, efficiency goes to be a lot the identical, although after all the explanation we’re retesting is as a result of the 10700K/10700F might be had for much less.
The Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order outcomes are fascinating and a bit odd as a result of the 10700K is as much as 7% quicker than the 11700K and 5800X at 1440p. Much more odd, whereas the typical body fee is 7% larger, the 1% low drops by 7%, probably leading to much less constant efficiency, although we must always observe, no noticeable variations had been seen.
In CoD Warzone, the Eleventh-gen 8-core processor is barely quicker than the Tenth-gen mannequin, delivering 3% larger frames at 1080p and 1440p. The 5800X was as much as 6% quicker than the 10700K.
The 11700K and 10700K ship nearly similar efficiency in Dying Stranding and which means the 5800X is ~8% quicker at 1080p and seven% quicker at 1440p. That is an affordable benefit for the Ryzen 7 processor, although body charges had been already excessively excessive, even at 1440p.
Resident Evil Village outcomes are loads like what we simply noticed in Dying Stranding, and that is to say the 5800X delivers a efficiency benefit at 1080p the place it was as much as 12% quicker. That margin was lowered to just about nothing at 1440p, although the 1% low efficiency was nonetheless a tad higher.
Earlier than we had discovered that Ryzen performs notably properly in Rainbow Six Siege and on this case even the older Tenth-gen sequence beats its newer technology. The 10700K is 14% quicker than the 11700K at 1080p and that meant the older Tenth-gen half was simply 3% slower than the 5800X. Then we see that margin solely eradicated at 1440p and 4K.
We take a look at Battle Thunder utilizing the Tank Battle CPU benchmark and for some cause the Intel CPUs create a powerful bottleneck on this take a look at, leading to nearly the identical efficiency seen throughout all three examined resolutions. This meant the 5800X was as much as 25% quicker than the 10700K, not a margin you’d usually count on to see.
The Intel CPUs additionally lagged behind in World Battle Z, no less than relative to the 5800X, which was as much as 27% quicker than the 10700K. The margin was lowered at 1440p after which neutralized at 4K, however nonetheless when CPU restricted AMD is way quicker for this title.
Now right here’s a have a look at all of the 32 video games we examined, beginning with the 1080p knowledge…
However earlier than we dig into the brand new knowledge, right here’s a fast recap for the Ryzen 7 5800X vs. Core i7-11700K comparability: beforehand we noticed that at worst the 5800X was 2% slower than the 11700K, which is a negligible distinction given we deem margins of 5% or much less to be a draw.
Which means for 75% of the video games examined, the margins had been meaningless as each CPUs enabled the identical gaming expertise. That does go away 8 video games the place the AMD processor did provide important efficiency positive factors, although you’d want to judge every title individually as in some cases we’re speaking about a whole lot of fps in a single participant title, like World Battle Z, for instance.
Remember the fact that these margins had been seen at 1080p utilizing a Radeon RX 6900 XT. For these gaming at 1440p the margins in most of those video games shrink, with World Battle Z and Battle Thunder being the one actual exceptions. General, the Ryzen 7 5800X is simply 3% quicker on common, so for the overwhelming majority of video games you’ll be taking a look at close to similar efficiency.
So how does the 5800X evaluate to the 10700K? Properly, about in addition to it did towards the 11700K, that means they’re about the identical. The Ryzen 7 processor is simply 5% quicker on common.
The margin at 1440p drops to only 3% in favor of the Ryzen processor. But once more the one outliers listed below are World Battle Z and Battle Thunder.
There have been 10 video games the place efficiency was similar, after which one other 8 video games the place the margin was 2% or much less. For greater than half the video games examined we discovered principally no efficiency distinction at 1440p with a high-end GPU.
Now for these of you questioning how the brand new 11700K stacks up towards the outdated 10700K, it appears like this. There are just a few first rate wins for both chip however put all of them collectively and the distinction is about 1% in favor of the 11700K.
In different phrases, they’re the identical for PC gaming and that’s what we present in our day one overview when evaluating the 11900K and 10700K. For that 10 recreation pattern utilizing the RTX 3090 and dual-rank/dual-channel DDR4-3200 CL14 reminiscence, the 11900K was simply 4% quicker.
At 1440p we discover that it’s a tie, the 11700K was as much as 6% quicker but in addition as much as 7% slower, so once more throughout the 32 recreation pattern we discover that they’re precisely the identical. The newer Eleventh-gen structure improves efficiency in some areas, whereas the elevated latency hurts efficiency in different areas.
Which CPU is Higher?
After we in contrast the Core i7-11700K and Ryzen 7 5800X earlier than, the purpose we wished to drive dwelling was: for gaming it doesn’t matter which processor you utilize, for essentially the most half the expertise goes to be precisely the identical. However when going past frames per second, there was a transparent winner within the 5800X. The massive wins for AMD contains higher energy effectivity and a superior platform that’s supported by a greater vary of reasonably priced motherboards and an improve path to 12 and even 16-core processors.
However after we look past the most recent technology 8-core processors, it’s onerous to disregard the Core i7-10700 sequence. In spite of everything, the Ryzen prices 30% greater than the 10700K and roughly 60% greater than the 10700F. Both Intel CPU might be paired with a $180 MSI Z490-A Professional for optimum efficiency.
Related high quality AMD B550 boards might be had for simply $120, making the Intel Z490 choice costlier which does sting. So the $100+ you save on the 10700K or 10700F isn’t as significant when you need to spend further on the motherboard.
For builders of a decent finances, we might advocate grabbing a B560 board as a substitute, although as we’ve discovered just lately, that may be a dicey proposition in itself. That stated, after in depth testing we’ve discovered the Asus TUF Gaming B560M-Plus to be an honest motherboard that’ll permit you get essentially the most out of a component just like the Core i7-10700K with out having to take away any energy limits, it’s full steam forward out of the field.
That makes the 10700K/B560 combo ~10% cheaper, or extra when you go for the 10700F. If all you care about is gaming FPS efficiency, then it’s straightforward to justify going with Intel. However when you place numerous worth in future upgrades, like the flexibility to leap up 16 cores on the identical motherboard, then it could be price spending the additional $60 or so on the 5800X/B550 combo.
It’s price noting that the Ryzen 5 5600X will ship the identical degree of gaming efficiency in all of the video games out there at this time, so at $300 it could be a greater different to the 10700 sequence as you continue to get that glorious energy effectivity and improve path.
Then, after all, when taking place that path you could possibly go for the considerably cheaper $170 Core i5-10400. Positive, it’s a bit slower than the 5600X, however it’s additionally nearly half the worth and can ship most efficiency on any B560 motherboard, although entry-level boards would possibly restrict your future improve choices.
Finally, there’s nobody most suitable choice for all players, as it should rely in your preferences and priorities, for instance: how a lot CPU efficiency do you really want, when and what you’re prone to improve to sooner or later, and most significantly, what’s your finances? Pricing can even fluctuate from area to area, we at all times depend on US pricing given it interprets to most different markets properly, and naturally, most of our readers are based mostly within the US.
But when the 10700K and 5800X are priced nearer in your area, then the Ryzen choice can be the extra apparent selection, and if pricing goes within the different path then it will be simpler to justify the financial savings by going with Intel. After all, don’t neglect to consider the price of the motherboard as that may make or break the deal.
Personally, my favourite combo proper now can be the Core i7-10700F at simply $270, which out of the field will ship nearly similar efficiency to the 10700K, so all the outcomes proven listed below are relevant to the extra reasonably priced F variant.
- Intel Core i7-10700F on Amazon
- Intel Core i7-10700K on Amazon
- Intel Core i7-11700K on Amazon
- AMD Ryzen 7 5800X on Amazon
- AMD Ryzen 9 5900X on Amazon
- Intel Z590 motherboards on Amazon
- AMD X570 motherboards on Amazon